Choice Or Chance Statistics In Your World 
Student Notes
Teachers Notes
Is It Butter?
 
Three People
 
More People
 

Taste Testing

Is It Butter?
Hazel is given a piece of bread, spread with either butter or margarine. She is asked to decide which it is, by guessing

The chance of being right (R), just by guessing, is 1/2.

If two people did the test, the tree diagram would look like this:


Figure 2 - Tree diagram showing outcome for two people.

The column headed 'Outcome' tells you how many were right (R) and wrong (W) each time.

These results are he summarized in Table 2.

Number right Possible ways Number of ways Probability
0 WW 1 1/4
1 RW, WR 2 2/4 = 1/2
2 RR 1 1/4
Total   4 1

Table 2 - Summarized results for two people.

This shows that if both people guess, it is most likely that one person will get it right.

 

Three People
Suppose the test is done by three people. Figure 4 on Page R2 shows only part of the relevant tree diagram.

  1. Complete it, again assuming that each person guesses.
  2. Complete the column headed 'Outcome'. The first one is done for you.

This time there are 8 (= 2 x 2 x 2 = 23) possible outcomes. The probability of each outcome is therefore 1/8.

  1. Complete the column headed 'Probability'.

Use your tree diagram to find:

  1. Probabifity (all 3 right)
  2. Probability (exactly 2 right)
  3. Probability (exactly 1 right)
  4. Probabifity (no one right)
  5. Use your answers to complete Table 7 on page R2 which shows the summarized results for three people.

 

More People

  1. Is the probability of one person out of two guessing correctly the same as two people out of four guessing correctly? Write down what you think.

Figure 5 on page R2 shows the tree diagram when four people guess. It is not complete.

  1. Complete it, and the columns headed 'Outcome' and 'Probability', again assuming everyone guesses.

Notice there are now 16 (= 2 x 2 x 2 x 2 = 24) possible outcomes.

Use the tree diagram to find:

  1. Probability (all 4 right)
  2. Probability (exactly 3 right)
  3. Probability (exactly 2 right)

See also if you can answer these questions:

  1. What is the most likely number of people to guess correctly?
  2. Is the probability of two out of four getting it right the same as the probability of one out of two getting it right? Use your answers to e and D1c.
  3. Was your answer to D3a correct?
  4. *What is the probability of at least one person being right when four people do the test?
  5. *What is the probability of at least two people being wrong when four people do the test?

 

Back